Remember the real estate market in early 2022? Homes were selling within days, often with multiple offers, no conditions and prices well above asking. Even properties needing significant renovations were attracting eager buyers.
In that kind of market, selling a home wasn't particularly difficult. Buyers were competing for limited inventory, and the market was doing much of the heavy lifting. Almost any competent realtor could list a property and attract serious interest.
Those days are behind us, at least for now.
In a balanced or buyer's market, homeowners face a different reality. Buyers have more choices, take longer to make decisions and negotiate harder. Some homes sit on the market for weeks or months.
That doesn't mean you can't sell your home for a good price. It means the strategy, effort and skill of your real estate agent matter considerably more.
So, what separates a good realtor from an average one?
What Makes a Good Realtor?
A good realtor does much more than list your property, arrange showings and negotiate an offer. They're your strategist, marketer, communicator, problem-solver and advocate throughout one of the largest financial transactions you'll make.
Here are seven qualities that become particularly important when the market isn't working in your favour.
1. They Communicate Clearly and Consistently
Selling a home can be stressful, especially when it takes longer than expected.
A good realtor doesn't leave you wondering what's happening. They provide regular updates on showings, buyer feedback, competing properties and market changes. More importantly, they explain what the information means and what they recommend doing about it.
They're responsive. When you call, text or email, you shouldn't have to chase them down.
And when difficult conversations are necessary, they don't avoid them. Whether discussing a price adjustment or explaining why an offer deserves consideration, they provide straightforward advice rather than simply telling you what you want to hear.
Good communication builds trust, reduces uncertainty and helps you make informed decisions.
2. Other Realtors Want to Work With Them
Here's something many sellers overlook: your realtor's relationships with other real estate agents can influence your selling experience.
When a buyer's agent calls with questions, requests a showing or wants to discuss an offer, how does your realtor respond?
Are they accessible, professional and cooperative? Do they return calls promptly? Are they helpful when challenges arise?
Real estate transactions involve two sides, and strong working relationships make negotiations and problem-solving smoother.
This doesn't mean your realtor should give anything away to make a deal happen. The best realtors know how to be collaborative while fiercely protecting their client's interests.
3. They're Creative and Proactive
When homes were selling themselves, there wasn't much incentive to think outside the box.
In a slower market, creativity matters.
A good realtor understands that putting a listing on MLS, posting some photos and hosting an open house may not be enough.
They find ways to make your property stand out.
Perhaps that means identifying a different target audience, creating a compelling video, highlighting overlooked features or reaching out directly to agents with suitable buyers.
For example, a large bungalow might appeal to families, but it could also attract downsizers seeking main-floor living. A creative realtor recognizes these opportunities and adjusts the marketing accordingly.
The objective isn't simply more exposure. It's generating interest from the right buyers.
4. They Understand Your Needs and Provide Support Beyond the Sale
Selling a home involves much more than putting a sign on the lawn. Depending on your circumstances, you may need considerable help preparing your home, managing the process and planning your next move.
This is particularly true for seniors downsizing after living in the same home for decades.
You might need help decluttering, organizing and deciding what to keep, donate or discard. Perhaps you need a handyman, painter or professionals to help with packing and moving.
You may also need recommendations on where to move next, whether that's a smaller home, condominium or retirement residence.
A good realtor recognizes that every homeowner has different needs, and their role should extend beyond simply selling the property.
They should have access to trusted professionals who can help. And for homeowners who don't want to coordinate everything themselves, an exceptional realtor may offer comprehensive support, helping manage the various parts of the transition.
For seniors, working with a realtor who specializes in helping older adults can make a significant difference. They understand the emotional and practical challenges of downsizing and can guide you through the process at a comfortable pace.
The right realtor doesn't just ask, "How can I sell your house?"
They ask, "What do you need to make this entire transition easier?"
5. They're Persistent and Follow Through
One of the biggest differences between an average realtor and an exceptional one is what happens after someone views your home.
Does your realtor follow up with the buyer's agent? Do they ask thoughtful questions about the buyer's interest or concerns? Do they explore opportunities to continue the conversation?
Or do they simply wait for the phone to ring?
In a buyer's market, persistence matters.
A buyer who initially seemed uninterested might reconsider after receiving additional information. Concerns might be resolved through clarification or further discussion.
Not every follow-up leads to an offer, but opportunities are easily missed when nobody takes the initiative to pursue them.
6. They're Strategic About Pricing and Marketing
Pricing a home correctly is important in every market, but mistakes can be especially costly when buyers have alternatives.
A good realtor understands your neighbourhood, comparable sales, current competition and buyer behaviour.
They don't simply suggest a price that makes you happy or wins them the listing. They explain the reasoning behind their recommendation, including the risks of overpricing.
They also recognize that different properties require different approaches.
A downtown condo, suburban family home and luxury property attract different audiences. Their marketing should reflect those differences.
And when a strategy isn't delivering results, they evaluate the evidence, discuss options and make adjustments.
Strategy isn't just having a plan. It's measuring results and adapting when necessary.
7. You Know They're in Your Corner
Perhaps the most important quality is also the hardest to measure.
Do you genuinely believe your realtor is working in your best interests?
When negotiations become difficult, do they advocate for you? When problems arise, do they help resolve them? When the process becomes frustrating, do they remain engaged?
A good realtor doesn't disappear when the easy work is finished.
They're willing to have uncomfortable conversations, put in extra effort and stand up for your interests.
You should feel they care about your outcome, not just completing the transaction.
You want someone who treats your sale with the care and commitment they would bring to selling their own home.
Should You Hire a Friend or Family Member as Your Realtor?
This is a question many homeowners struggle with.
The answer? It depends.
There's absolutely nothing wrong with hiring someone you know personally. A trusted relationship can be an advantage.
If your friend or family member has demonstrated competence, understands your market, communicates effectively and works hard, they may be an excellent choice.
But problems arise when the decision is based primarily on personal obligation or a discounted commission.
Perhaps you don't want to hurt someone's feelings. Maybe they've offered a substantial discount. Or perhaps you've assumed that because they're family, they'll work harder.
Those aren't necessarily good reasons to hire someone.
Ask yourself: If this person weren't my friend or relative, would I still choose them?
Would you trust their pricing advice? Are you confident in their marketing strategy and negotiating abilities? Can you have honest conversations when you disagree?
A discounted commission can save money, but not if it compromises service or your eventual selling price.
Have a candid conversation about expectations before signing a listing agreement. The personal relationship should be an added benefit, not a substitute for professional competence.
The Bottom Line: Your Realtor Matters More When the Market Gets Tough
In a hot seller's market, even an average strategy can produce impressive results. When buyers compete aggressively, there's more room for mistakes.
But in a balanced or buyer's market, those mistakes can become costly.
Overpricing, weak marketing, poor communication, missed follow-ups and ineffective negotiation can mean longer selling times, greater stress and potentially less money in your pocket.
Choosing the right realtor won't guarantee a quick sale or particular price. Market conditions and buyer demand always influence the outcome.
But a capable, committed realtor can improve how your home is positioned, how opportunities are pursued and how challenges are managed.
When the market isn't doing the heavy lifting, you need a realtor who's prepared to do it.